Some insurers deny claims for mental telehealth services
Table of Contents
00:04
(MUSIC)
JOSH: ONE OF THE NATION'S
LARGEST INSURANCE COMPANIES HAS
REVERSED ITS DECISION TO DENY A
TEXAS WOMAN'S MENTAL HEALTH
NEEDS.
THE CHANGE COMES AFTER OUR
INVESTIGATORS STARTED LOOKING
INTO TIPS THAT INSURERS ARE NOT
COVERING MENTAL TELEHEALTH
SERVICES AMID STAY-AT-HOME
ORDERS DURING THE COVID 19
PANDEMIC.
INVESTIGATOR JODY BARR
DISCOVERED MANY OTHER TEXANS ARE
STILL STRUGGLING WITH THIS
PROBLEM.
GORDON: THIS IS HOW I'VE BEEN
SPENDING MY TIME WHEN I'M NOT
WORKING FROM HOME. IT KIND OF IS
A WAY TO PASS THE HOURS AND NOT
SPEND ALL MY TIME ON NETFLIX.
JODY: MEGHANN GORDON'S
EMBROILED IN A FIGHT WITH BLUE
CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF
TEXAS--TRYING TO GET THE
INSURANCE GIANT TO COVER VISITS
TO HER THERAPIST.
GORDON: ""DEPENDING ON HOW
LONG WE'RE DOING WORK AT HOME, I
MIGHT ACTUALLY GET GOOD.""
JODY: GORDON HAS HEALTH
INSURANCE THROUGH HER TEACHING
JOB. SHE NEVER HAD A PROBLEM
BEFORE, BUT WHEN HER THERAPIST
WAS FORCED INTO PROVIDING
SESSIONS OVER A TELEHEALTH
PORTAL GORDON SAYS HER INSURER
01:06
PUT THE BRAKES ON COVERAGE.
WHEN I CALLED THEM, THEY TOLD
ME THAT THEY WOULD NOT COVER
THAT VISIT, EVEN THOUGH SHE'S A
PARTICIPATING PROVIDER AND
THEY'VE COVERED IN PERSON VISITS
BEFORE.""
JB: YOUR INSURANCE PROVIDER
IS TELLING YOU, BECAUSE YOU
CAN'T SEE YOUR PROVIDER IN
PERSON, WE'RE NOT PAYING FOR IT?
MG: YES, EXACTLY. THEY'RE
ONLY WILLING TO PAY FOR IN
PERSON VISITS.
JODY: SHE'S REPEATED THIS
SAME PROCESS FOR THE PAST THREE
WEEKS--
(CLICKING)
IN A FEW WORDS, PLEASE TELL
ME THE REASON FOR YOUR CALL.
MG: ""COVERAGE.""
JODY: SHE KNOWS THE AUTOMATED
MENU BY HEART--
GORDON: ""THIS IS MY 4TH TIME
CALLING ABOUT THIS.""
JODY: B-C-B-S TOLD HER
ALTHOUGH THEY DENIED HER
COVERAGE--HER REQUEST FOR
TELEHEALTH COVERAGE IS "IN
REVIEW."
MG: ""IS THAT STILL IN REVIEW,
ARE THEY STILL MAKING A DECISION
ON THAT?""
BCBS: ""RIGHT, RIGHT, IT'S
STILL IN REVIEW.""
MG: ""DO YOU KNOW HOW LONG
IT'S GOING TO BE IN REVIEW, I'VE
TRIED TO FOLLOW UP EVERY WEEK A
COUPLE OF TIMES A WEEK-.""
BCBS: ""NO, MA'AM.""
GORDON: ""FOR PEOPLE ON
SELF-FUNDED OR EMPLOYER-FUNDED
PLANS, THEY DON'T REALLY HAVE
ANY OPTIONS, IT'S WHAT THE
02:06
INSURANCE COMPANY DECIDES TO
COVER AND UNFORTUNATELY THEY'RE
CHOOSING NOT TO COVER THESE
VISITS.""
JODY: PROVIDERS TELL US, THE
PROBLEMS REST WITH PRIVATE,
EMPLOYER-FUNDED HEALTH PLANS.
SOME PLANS PROVIDE TELEHEALTH
COVERAGE FOR BEHAVIORAL
HEALTH--SOME DON'T--EVEN UNDER
THE SAME INSURER.
ROBERTSON: ""YOU JUST GO ON
HERE AND JUST HIT-CLICK VIDEO,
START TALKING.""
JODY: ANITA ROBERTSON TREATS
DEPRESSION AND ANXIETY.
AND LIKE MOST OTHER THERAPISTS
IN TEXAS--IS ONLY SEEING
PATIENTS OVER THE INTERNET RIGHT
NOW.
ROBERTSON: ""ALL OF THIS IS
HIPPA SECURE.""
JODY: WITH SO MUCH ISOLATION
SOMETHING THAT COULD BE A
SUICIDE RISK FACTOR. SHE SAYS
PATIENTS NEED HELP NOW MORE THAN
EVER.
THE BARRIER, SHE SAYS, IS
INSURANCE DENIALS.
DESPITE THE FINANCIAL GAMBLE
SHE'S STILL TREATING THOSE WHO
NEED HER MOST.
ROBERTSON: ""ETHICALLY AS A
PROVIDER, I FEEL LIKE IT WOULD
BE UNETHICAL TO STOP TREATMENT
JUST BECAUSE PEOPLE CAN'T PAY IN
THIS TIME BECAUSE IT WOULD
CREATE WAY MORE HARM AND YET
IT'S ALSO UNSUSTAINABLE FOR ME
03:07
LONG-TERM TO BE ABLE TO SEE
CLIENTS FOR COPAYS OR FOR
NOTHING.""
JB: ""HOW CAN A TEXAN NOT HAVE
A PAINTING OF A LONGHORN?""
MG: ""I THINK THAT MIGHT HAVE
TO BE THE NEXT ONE...
JODY: HOURS AFTER WE ASKED
GORDON'S INSURER ABOUT HER
CASE--IT REVERSED ITS
DECISION--OFFERING FULL COVERAGE
THROUGH APRIL.
GORDON'S WORRIES--THOUGH-- ARE
FOR OTHER TEXANS.
A REASONABLE PERSON WOULD
ARGUE, IT'S BETTER TO PAY FOR A
TELEHEALTH VISIT THAN FOR
SOMEONE TO NOT BE SEEN AT ALL.
IS THAT FAIR?""
MG: ""YES, I WOULD AGREE.
JOSH: JODY JOINS US NOW.
SO HOW DO WE STOP THIS FROM
HAPPENING SO MORE TEXANS AREN'T
DENIED COVERAGE?
JODY: WELL, JOSH, EXPERTS IN
THE INSURANCE BILLING FIELD TELL
ME THE FIX WOULD COME AT THE
FEDERAL LEVEL AND IT WOULD COME
WITH A CHANGE IN LAW.
WE SPOKE WITH CONGRESSMEN LLOYD
DOGGETT AND MICHAEL MCCAUL'S
OFFICES.
BOTH TELL ME THEY'RE WORKING TO
FIGURE OUT HOW THIS DISPARITY
EXISTS IN THE FIRST PLACE FROM
PLAN-TO-PLAN
AND WHAT THEY MIGHT BE ABLE TO
DO ABOUT IT.
JOSH: JODY, THANK YOU VERY
MUCH.
(SWOOSH)
(MUSIC)
JOSH: AS COVID-19 SPREADS
FASTER IN TEXAS - FRUSTRATION
GROWS WITH PEOPLE WHO WON'T
04:08
FOLLOW SOCIAL DISTANCING RULES.
QUIT BEING AN [EXPLETIVE].
THAT'S MY MESSAGE, CANDIDLY. GET
OVER YOURSELVES.
JOSH: WHY ONE STATE LEADER
SAYS IT'S NOW UP TO INDIVIDUAL
TEXANS TO STEP UP AND STOP THE
SPREAD OF THE CORONAVIRUS.
(MUSIC)
This is our home.
We've never seen it
look quite like this.
But there's
no mistaking it.
And it's our