Direct Primary Care Webinar - Part 1 - June 8th 2020
Table of Contents
- Well hello good morning everyone here from the Alliance my first day back at...
- Has to PA oh the antidote they've identified a hospital 30 minutes away on...
- Let's look at version 3.
- The health care Thank You dr.
- There true leading for those things then the patients will be more likely to...
- Clinic that we're going to be offering but...
00:00
well hello good morning everyone here
from the Alliance my first day back at
the Alliance office thank you for
joining us for the first of a two-part
webinar series on direct primary care
I am Melina cam bitsy and I'm the senior
vice president of business development
and strategic marketing here at the
Alliance so before I introduce our
presenters I want to talk a little that
you're all in newt mode and if you have
00:31
questions during the webinar please send
them in the chat box if you want to say
something we'll respond to someone
during the discussion please raise your
hand as it is shown here on the screen
so that the green arrow is pointing up
on the hand icon so it is my pleasure to
have here with us today dr. keller Patel
chief medical officer at practive MD and
dr. David Asher president and founder of
01:02
reform medicine I will introduce each
one of the speakers and then we will
start this presentation with a couple
slides from the Alliance and then over
to dr. Patel
so dr. Patel of Nan dr. Patel for a
couple years now and he he is known and
he continues to disrupt the healthcare
industry was his unique views on the
right care he currently serves as I said
is the chief medical officer for Pratt's
of Mt accompany laser focused on
01:34
providing the patients they serve that
right care and we'll talk more about
that in this presentation
proactivity a couple things about
proactive MD and its relationship with
the Alliance productivity is the company
that the Alliance after a rigorous RFP
has chosen to help us bring high value
primary care to the markets and the
employers we serve in the form of
community health centers that are shared
by employers we will talk a little more
later about this and also in more
02:05
details in the next webinar and also
following other presentations as well
dr. Patel will discuss how and why
traditional healthcare doesn't have the
systems in place to deliver integrated
health and what we as employers can do
to provide quality care to patients and
incentivize providers appropriately he
will also provide an overview of direct
primary care what it is and how it works
then the second speaker for today is dr.
uh sure
dr. David uh sure founded before
02:40
medicine and as a matter of fact will
work closely with dr. uh sure because
several of the Alliance member employers
are utilizing his services he reformed
medicine is a low overhead family
medical and medical weight loss practice
that is affordable to employers and
consumers alike working under a purely
private medical model doctor uh sure can
innovate and offer to patients and
employers creative affordable solutions
that large health systems are slower to
03:10
adopt in his former life dr. Asher was a
family doctor at the Mayo Clinic in Eau
Claire and he served as the medical
director of weight management services
and chair of the Department of Family
Practice at Mayo dr. Asher will discuss
his background at Mayo and how this
experience influenced him in 2011 to
found a direct primary care practice
that focuses on a quarter of our new
primary care we work as I said very
closely with dr. Usher and I would also
like to note that there are several
03:42
independent fiercely independent
extraordinarily innovative services
solutions providers in Wisconsin and the
Alliance is proud and happy and looks
forward to closely working with all
independent providers so why not let me
talk a little bit about why direct
primary care I promise I will not speak
a lot as we want to hear from our
distinguished guests
04:11
so um why direct primary care as you
know the mission of the Alliance is to
work on behalf of employers to negotiate
better rates and higher quality with
existing providers but we're all
beholden to primary care as is delivered
by the existing health care
system and that means means a rigid
appointments limited options and as we
all have experienced multiple tests and
other treatments outside of the primary
04:41
care setting but direct primary care is
different it is different because DPC's
delivered outside the traditional health
systems which means that providers have
different incentives instead of aiming
to generate more specialty care more
tests more specialists and more visits
DPC and we also by the way often refer
to DBC as advanced primary care or
high-value primary care exists to
generate better health for employed
employees and affordability for the
05:14
employers who sponsor their health
benefits so for these reasons and also
for all the reasons we will discuss
today the alliance of chosen direct to
employers primary care as a strategic
focus for 2020 and beyond in
collaboration with practive MD were
opening a new Community Health Center in
Hungary in the fall of 2020 either
September or October of this year we
already have a number of interested
employers and we'll be using this this
is a shared sight clinic so no one
05:44
employer has to go at it alone we look
forward to sharing more details with you
in the future but if you have interest
in participating please reach out to me
we hope that dr. Patel and dr. Oscar can
talk through but why they decided to
offer this service and on June 25th we
will hear from a panel of our employers
talking about how they're offering
direct primary care and what it means to
their business and their employees so
without further ado dr. Patel I am gonna
turn this presentation over to you and
06:14
Paul turn it over to dr. K yours
dr. patel's control there we go
fantastic first of all milena I really
appreciate the opportunity to speak to
the group and deliver the message what I
wanted to set there share with you is
this is a a major automotive
manufacturer that makes these cars and
the supplied
has been delayed by about three or four
months because of the current events due
06:46
to the delay in the supply event they
were not able to deliver this specific
fiber glass that they use for the body
of this vehicle so they had to look at
options of shutting down the entire
plant 3,000 employees will be laid off
these 3,000 men and women would line up
for unemployment all tomorrow morning it
put a burden to the entire nation these
3,000 men and women will have to think
twice what they were put on the table
07:17
for their kids tonight for dinner and so
it's all because of the supply chain
it's all because of the current events
now their rival competitor uses the same
alloy material the fiberglass and they
actually have 50,000 extra sheets that
they can essentially lend out so you
would think logically what would happen
is these two CEOs would get together on
07:50
a phone call and say hey we got a
shutout plate down you have material
kill me borrow that sell it maybe make a
little profit off it whatever they do
you can actually sustain the other
company but that's not how it's gonna
work
right this rival is going to figure out
how to take a baseball bat and chop the
other guy in the knees with both
kneecaps at the same time this is how
the market is today but most of the
08:21
manufacturing market space let's flip
this round I have a patient in the ICU a
hospital that is has a very specific
poisoning it needs this specific
antidote to PA em and this hospital in
the ICU doesn't have a two vials but we
actually need about ten we're short at
least eight or ten vials so the next
logical thing the pharmacist will do up
collar on and find out
08:53
has to PA oh the antidote they've
identified a hospital 30 minutes away on
the south end of the town so now you got
to pharmacist they've identified that
they can deliver this medicine instead
of the hospital a saying hey I'm gonna
send my security guy to pick it up guess
what the south end Haas was gonna say
stop I wouldn't send my guy to you
because he'll save me 30 minute commute
time now these two pharmacists didn't
09:24
have to call their CEOs did have to call
the directors it was just the right
thing to do it truly delivers the right
care
I mean it's innate it's the basic
instinct that's what you would do
because you are dealing with another
product here and we need health care so
overall you know when you look at the
health care today I know we have a lot
of sort of things to fix and gaps in
care but overall the heart is there but
it's the problem is how are we
09:55
delivering it it makes it so difficult
to Delors certain things is why we delay
in some of our care so we have a good
group melina today in this audience what
if we took the entire audience and
divided into six separate different
areas or seven different groups and I
said I want to build this car I want the
fastest the most efficient and safest
vehicle on the planet and we divide the
room into six and we have unlimited
money unlimited budget and I sell Group
10:28
a go find the best brakes money can buy
Group B go find the best transmission
money and buy in Group C etcetera exert
get the best of the best products that
the industry has to offer so we get the
best of everything then we bring it back
into the central office and say let's
get the top-notch hundred best mechanics
in the world again money is not an
option it's unlimited money so you would
10:59
get the best mechanics money can buy you
got the best
money can buy now I ask you the group
you can even put it in the chat line how
long will it take to build this car six
months one year two years five years how
long do you think it'll take the best
mechanics the best parts all in one
warehouse you just got to put it
together and the answer to this is we
could be here another 10 years my
lifetime and we will never have this car
11:31
because no products talk to each other
do you think the BMW is going to talk to
the Porsche and the Porsche is gonna
talk to GM and GM is going to talk to
Chrysler it'll never happen they are not
going to talk so it's not that we don't
have the best ingredients it's not that
we don't have a recipe it's just how to
package it and deliver it reaches can't
do it because there's no communications
nothing talks doesn't healthcare today
feel like this healthcare today think
12:03
about it we have the best surgeons the
best Oh our best prosthesis the best
medications antibiotics cancer medicine
best of the best money can buy we have
the best surgeons best internist
best family Doc's money can buy yet we
just can't deliver and so when you start
looking at this you really realize that
if we can make an impact in the delivery
we can maybe make a big dent so our
12:35
focus over the last 10 years has been
how do we change the delivery I'm not
here to invent the next drug I don't
want to invent the next cat-scan machine
that does 300 you know bites
I just want to recraft the delivery if
we can recap the delivery we can
actually make an impact so I want to
spend a few minutes and just build and
look and view what the health care
system looks like today so if you were
to take all the services right the
13:07
doctors and nurses and the health care
system is delivering and put it from
left to right and the left being the
most minimal care and the left
the right being the most complex care so
you can go from Wellness Urgent Care
medications
you know imaging specialty care hard
cats and then going to Serge his ICUs
and so forth so you going in a
progression of complexity of care so
that's the floor this is what healthcare
is delivering then you have the
13:38
consumers the patients now today's world
patients can access care at any point
they can go straight to a are they can
go straight to the primary care doc they
can't even go straight to the
cardiologists get a cab tomorrow morning
so they can go anywhere in the spectrum
then on top is the payers right the TPA
is the employers the pair and the
consultants and so far you gotta stop
cross on top so if you look at this
house it's simple three pieces the
14:10
provider of care the patients in the
pair's all these three who's the most
incentivized to put value in healthcare
or look at value every time something's
being deliver out of this three pieces
the payers the consumers or the
providers its the payers so I mean the
consumers don't really care some
insurance is paying for it they don't
14:41
care it's just a copay and the providers
have a system that doesn't incentivize
them to make anyone healthy so it's
really the payers are the only ones
today that are interested in fixing the
health system and that's why this
conversation is to say how can you as
the representation of the employers in
the consultants of the employers fix
help cut cost and put value back into
healthcare but the problem with today is
15:13
we have this sort of broken system on
top of that on the bottom we put a
broken electronic medical system so you
put an electronic medical record system
in there and guess what no one's talking
the CT guy doesn't talk to the lab lab
guy doesn't talk to the cardiologist
cardiologist
doesn't talk to the internist nothing is
talking and in my lifetime it will not
talk we've been talking about this for
the last 10 15 years that there's gonna
be a uniform one electronic medical
record it is not happening it will not
15:46
happen so you have this electronic
Marburger is a foundation in a semi
broken system that now you made the
entire system dysfunctional and that's
why our cost is high because there's
replication of data replication of test
replication of information and we were
just having an excessive cost so as a
solution and everyone on this meaning is
aware that we can really unlock the
16:21
existing model and break it apart a
little bit and reglue it in the right
place we can create a version 1.0 direct
primary care and what I mean by that is
we would take what's on the bottom the
basics the Wellness the urgent care the
medication dispensing take some of those
basic principles or services and move it
to the right side
of the pillar and by doing that what
we're doing we're moving to the right
16:53
side it's one block at a time in
allowing that Health Center or the
clinic version 1.0 deliver that part of
the care directly to the patients and
it's an evolution that's what we've seen
you know we've seen the first evolution
of the direct primary care and now the
second evolution is evolving and by just
doing this version 1.0 there's about a
seven eight 10% depends on what the
stats you have a reduction in that
overall health care spent by that
17:24
particular employer so let's say you go
to the version 2.0 it's simple all we
are doing is taking what we can manage
from the bottom move those bricks to the
right-hand side one by one whatever we
can manage what everyone can chew
whatever we can master so what if we
took now may the primary care consistent
same primary care not like an urgent
care where you have different doctor
every day but the same primary care then
you have more involvement you have more
17:56
chronic disease management so you're
moving these bricks from the bottom to
the right and as you do guess what
happens to the savings it goes up so
we're essentially that a goal is to say
one by one piece by piece
what can we move and we can't move it
all but we can make a big impact so if
we were to just simply go to this
version 2.0 you can easily say 15 18
percent on the total healthcare spent
18:26
let's look at version 3.0 so what do we
mean by that again take the blocks for
the bottom of move along what if we were
to take some of the consulting
specialties we were to negotiate imaging
some of these other areas where we're
not touching if we can manage that we
can increase the savings and do the
right thing and maintain quality so when
we started looking at this and said okay
are we know who's doing this right I
mean sorry I Google this about eight
18:58
years ago
and there were very few employers that
were doing something creative but this
is a recent data that I was able to pull
up last week 2018 top 10 employers in
the country here they are
top 10 what do you think they have in
common we think these 10 guys have in
common
this green illustrates that these folks
these companies who represent the top 10
employers in the country have a centres
19:29
of excellent identified that means they
actually looked at and said here's our
surgery here's our cost how can we get
value for our dollar and maintain
quality so they developed centers of
excellence and if you recall Walmart was
leading the pack October 2012 they
publicly announced to all of their
employees that if you are going to have
these five major surgeries that you will
get it done in our specialty areas by
choice and if you move the traffic there
20:00
that they'll eliminate the copay so it
was incentivizing the employees to shift
to the centers of excellence and soon
later next year Lowe's and PepsiCo and
frito-lay they all followed suit and
Walmart pretty much let the pack in 2012
what did they do what did Walmart say
they understand the entire complexity of
health care so what they said is that we
have X number of let's say knee
surgeries hundred researchers so they
20:31
said how can I take my hundred knee
surgeries up give it up to the best
highly qualified surgeon and get a price
break so I'm putting value in quality
and they were looking at surges five
major surgeries what I suggest is they
started there because they could in a
global in a 50000 view when you sit with
executives they're looking and saying
what do we do at an executive level to
make an impact on the health care cost
that would be it but we as a employer
group for smaller employers need not
21:03
look at that we need to look at it and
say look we need to make sure that the
hundred knee surgeries that were
supposed to be done could it be only 80
if we do
the right primary care right specialty
right imaging and directed them
appropriately
maybe those hundred knee surges actually
could have been just eighty and if
that's the case that we at least can say
that we didn't even need to do twenty
surgeons it could have been managed
conservatively so we need to look at it
and pin it from both ends we need to be
21:34
able to go from the lowest complexity
and it kind of meet somewhere in between
so when you go out into the it you know
the environment and looking at options
for your employer's what are you looking
for my suggestion maybe these are the
few things that you can keep on your
checklist or like shopping checklist so
to speak what are you speaking to some
of the folks that you want to partner
with first thing is in my mind we you
22:07
have to develop a quarterback for your
system so if I were to ask you who's
gotten the highest IQ in a football team
who would it be the quarterback
average IQ of a quarterbacks about 145
IQ this guy the quarterback knows where
each one of the team players are who's
gonna catch his ball who's left-handed
who's right-handed whose wrist is
hurting who is ankylosaurus now on a
22:39
game today he knows where to throw that
ball and this is the same analogy I'm
using for our specialty care the
quarterback has to be the family doc who
has the ability to navigate all the
specialty care and know where the
patient is gonna be pinned and as soon
as the specialty care sees a patient it
needs to be pinned back to the primary
care to reprocess what the next move is
gonna be so unless you have the right
23:09
clinician in the center it's not gonna
work out because you the key thing is
not just to see a patient for flu and
cold a coffin UTI is to say how can we
manage the referral center how can you
manage the specialty center how can we
manage the data that comes
back who do we send the patient to
that's the quarterback unless you
identified that key person in the health
center it's not gonna go anywhere so the
next thing is whenever you set up the
23:42
like the workflow and see how many
patients you have and the volume and
what the model should look like it
becomes easy to get into this loop of
saying let's see five patients an hour
because it'll cut cost but the key thing
is more time you spend with the patient
take medicine fifty years back more time
you spend with the patient and more
you're gonna find issues that you can
resolve and the least expensive care is
a primary care so the more time you give
24:14
to the primary care and the patient the
better off you are because you're gonna
decrease some of the specialty referral
patterns and so think about it why is a
quarterback the smartest guy on the team
of course he's IQs 145 that gives him a
advantage why else he's in the locker
room spending time with other team
players he knows everything about the
team player who's not on their game this
is exactly what I'm driving at if the
physician and the patients spend time
more time the better to believe because
24:45
they'll understand what the next plan
will be so going back to saying how do
you put value into the health equation
and you know in a simple CFO's mind it's
like if I were to buy this suit and it's
fifty dollars I got it from TJ Maxx you
know I'm gonna say wow this is 50 bucks
good quality cost is $50 there by the
suit what if this was a $2,000 suit all
these great feels good but $2,000 you're
25:15
not getting value on that so you know
it's the fullness quality of a cost but
in health care it's not this is not the
formula in health care this is a CFO's
formula in the normal marketplace in
health care if your cardiologist is
amazing guy good quality normal cost
good value but on two o'clock in the
afternoon on Sunday if that cardiologist
is not going to take care of you then
what you get you
no access to cardiologist at 2:00 and
afternoon on Sunday you got zero value
25:45
so unless you have access to care you
you will not get the value need yet one
more step forward we need to look at is
who's offering you outcomes
who's measuring outcomes that's gonna
add value and this is what I'm driving
at is the version direct primary care
version 1 version 2 version 3 whatever
whatever methodology you want to use is
that we're adding more parameters to
measure more parameters to be
accountable for so if you are getting
26:17
outcomes measured and someone actually
came to you and said we will measure
outcomes and you will pay on outcomes
then you have just increased the value
there's more skin in the game then
centers are there and it's very
practical if you think about it so I'm
gonna end with this if I were to ask the
group what is the leading 3rd leading
cause of death in United States it's not
cancer it's not breast cancer it's not
the cardiovascular disease it's not COPD
26:50
and smoking it happens to be healthcare
related medical errors it's 2.5 jumbo
jet 747 fully loaded crashing into the
Atlantic every night that's the number
of deaths are occurring directly related
with medical errors there's gaps in care
gaps in the air we have to have zero
tolerance for errors and it's
unfortunate it's not even possible for
27:21
30 years so it's no longer used it's
unfortunate that our patients our public
gets their news from CNN because it's
not news it doesn't hit CNN it's 30
years old damage the same it hasn't
changed a bit
so there's a lot of room for improvement
in every facet we can make an impact
this group can make an impact you can
make an impact in the employer market
that you serve in the way you can change
27:52
the health care
Thank You dr. Patel thank you very much
we already have several questions that
have come in but we will address them at
the end
dr. Ashur I would like to turn it over
to you now sir and you have the next 20
minutes I had had a ton of experience
and kind of leadership and understanding
some of the things that went into
running a clinical practice so in in
primary care it's kind of a structural
problem and that is that it pays a
family doctor or a primary care
28:28
physician more to see two short
appointments than it does to spend one
long appointment so we make more money
if we see two 15-minute appointments
than if they see one 30-minute
appointment and that that's just going
to incentivize people to work faster and
see shorter appointments and so on so I
always wanted to take more time with my
patients so that was a bit of a problem
for me but what happened was when the
Affordable Care Act came along our
29:00
patients already were complaining of not
being able to pay their bills premiums
were going to go up out-of-pocket costs
were going to go up and so we decided to
step out of standard primary care
medicine and get into a direct pay model
I say primary care providers are
undervalued dr. Patel was mentioning
that really primary care should be your
quarterback and
and we've and I'll thank him for the
29:33
really high IQ reference although I
don't know that that applies to me but
your quarterback should really be the
one who knows where the ball is at all
times and knows what's coming up in the
game and so forth but primary-care again
because there of the reimbursement
structure it's really hard for us to do
that in the existing kind of
fee-for-service model so primary care
has kind of been bought up by the big
clinics primary care is now used as a
loss leader and a referral engine for
30:05
referring people into bigger cost higher
cost procedures that the clinic big this
multi specialty clinics and hospitals
would make more money on now and then
the patient even if they have good
insurance this year's charges becomes
next year's premiums as you all know so
every time this just escalates the cost
of things to the patient and basically
everybody involved this this slide maybe
you've seen something like this these
are from the Kaiser Family Foundation
30:37
but basically you can kind of see the
graph on the left over 20 years overall
premium costs have risen three hundred
and forty percent or seventeen percent a
year in this survey and if you look at
the employee contribution that's that's
gone from twenty four seven percent to
twenty eight percent so the employee
have seen basically a 360 percent rise
over that same 20 years so employers
paying employees are paying more and
more and more now if you look at the
31:09
graph on the right basically you can see
how much the deductibles or the amount
of money that the individuals on the
hook for even though they have insurance
has gone up over eight times what their
wages are earnings of Ghana
effectively what you're seeing is people
individuals knowing that cost of
everything is going up and that they are
on the hook for more people just sit at
home and delay care or avoid chronic
disease care because they know the cost
31:41
is so terrible and I was seeing this a
lot in the big system what you so what
you have that some of those insurance
but effectively they're medically
homeless because they won't come home
and see their primary care doctor
they'll just sit and wait until things
become really bad know that urgent care
or emergency room so we decided our why
excuse me why do we want to do what
we're doing we think that better health
32:11
care really starts with better primary
care and dr. Patel mentioned we we like
to think of it as high-value primary
care high-value primary care starts with
more time with patients better access
for patients to get to their providers
this leads to a deeper kind of more
trusting relationship with providers and
that trust really is a huge key when
we're recommending certain things and
and so on patients want to go with
32:42
somebody they trust one of the other
things is that we get to spend more time
addressing root causes of a lot of
problems in our case we we do a lot of
medical weight loss so we have kind of a
treat weight first a strategy rather
than kind of thinking overweight as a
cosmetic problem we see it as a root
cause to literally a couple hundred
different medical problems so we treat
that aggressively just like we would
high blood pressure diabetes overall you
see we refer much less because we have
33:14
more time with our patients dr. Patel
mentioned if you have more time you can
get to the root cause and address that
more readily in primary care it's more
affordable to patients and it yields a
better work style and a better lifestyle
for providers certainly and drink I make
a direct pay model allows for all of
that
one of the things that a direct pay
model though you can see whether you're
a benefits broker consultant or advisor
33:45
or an employer is the direct pay models
can be a little disruptive to be sure so
what we created back in 2011 started
with a combination of primary care
obesity care more time more access more
affordability and and it was better our
patients loved it one of the things just
a side note obesity is right up there
among the top killers about 300,000
34:17
deaths can be attributed to obesity
every year 42% of the population has
obesity and another 30% are overweight
or pre-owned ease so you really have to
have an aggressive effective strategy
for obesity and my humble opinion to be
doing real good primary care Hey in any
case at around 2013 a couple of years
and my first employer came to us and we
had some conversations about working
with membership model to do some near
34:48
site and on-site clinic work for them
and thus we kind of started down that
road as well basically this whole
foundation was built on the idea that we
did not want to get into the tail
chasing problem of building third-party
payers for a fee-for-service basis so
we've avoided that for all nine years of
our existence just to give you a sense
of the cost difference this is our
fee-for-service signs as you can see
down the right the far right side those
35:19
are most of these are pretty one-to-one
kind of comparisons but I just want to
give you a sense of the differential and
cost compared to a lot of the big
clinics here in town so what we started
doing is working with employers and what
we've learned over the years is
basically you want to create a
partnership we think of the patient's
financial health as being as important
to their overall health as their
physical well-being and their
psychological well-being
not doing well financially if they're
struggling that's going to lead to all
35:52
kinds of potential health problems
stress and alcohol and relationship
issues and so forth
and likewise employers have the same and
an analogous sense if the employers not
doing well financially they're they're
not going to be able to grow they're
gonna have to lay people off that are
benefits they might not be able to offer
and so so we see the employer in this
case kind of like we see our patients us
like this financial health thing is very
important so we partner with the patient
36:24
and the employer to try to be rolling
get them get us all rolling in the same
direction so that we wind up with
healthier employers in a better
financial situation also healthier
workforce for the employers so some of
the things we do with our employers is
initially you just get in there with
them and roll up our sleeves and try to
understand their health plan goals and
strategy we use high-value primary care
36:54
as a base we do it either in a mere site
model with our own clinics or if the
employer wants to do an on-site clinic
we can set one of those up as well and
just work right out of their space again
we this is all based on trusting
relationships with patients anything the
employer wants to do if if it doesn't
come through a trusted primary care
doctor that may be perceived as just
trying to cut costs if it makes really
good sense and it's really great care
and you're your quarterback is is out
37:26
there true leading for those things then
the patients will be more likely to
understand that we referral through the
providers network I don't have all of
our providers are trained to work very
specifically with each employers plan so
that we're sending them to places that
are going to be the best value for the
patient and the employer and then
there's dr. L mentioned there's at the
end of the day you want to be able to
talk about what you're doing well and so
we report data back to the employers
37:58
sometimes through their TPAs for return
on investment and
value of investment kinda determinations
so this is kind of where we've done we
started in 2011 but just me and my
medical assistant over there on the left
over nine years we've become two people
two twenty two people and we have went
from zero employer clients to eleven and
we're in four locations now including
one on-site clinic this is from our
on-site clinic they kind of publish this
data where it says the part of our
38:29
overall strategy we are they started
changing their strategy before they
brought us on you can see they already
kind of bent their cost curve
significantly even after adding us and
that first year their costs went down so
they're sitting on a whole different
trajectory now there's a seven million
dollar differential between what they
might have been paying if they'd have
stayed on the same trajectory versus
what they're doing now with our on-site
clinic as part of their strategy so how
the patients like this well as dr. Patel
mentioned this is a pretty popular way
39:01
to go and you have more time with your
patients and can really not only see
patients but actually hear them that
will get you a pretty high level Net
Promoter Score these are true true
things from people that have people have
said about us but we survey our patients
and 99% of them would would recommend
what we do to others so it's really it's
a popular it's a very great way for
patients to be seen the Cova 19 response
everybody's got one we have done the
39:32
spacing and done a lot of Eve is 'its I
don't want to read this whole list to
you but bottom line is we checked in
with employers frequently talk to them
about testing antibody testing and virus
testing and so on some unexpected
outgrowth of this something we weren't
thinking about top of mind is to be able
to do more telemedicine including their
medical weight loss program so it hasn't
been all bad and the cogut 19 side of
things but we've learned to adjust so
40:05
many half in summary basically primary
care should be viewed differently from
the rest of the more expensive
healthcare in that
it's something you want your patients to
use you want your people to be well just
like you want to change your oil and
have a good set of tires on your car you
expect to spend that money and you
budget for it primary care is something
you want to be utilized you want to do
preventive care if you have chronic
illness you want that well controlled
and then the insurance is for that other
40:37
high-cost stuff that comes along and so
you to get different outcomes from
primary care you kind of have to pay for
it differently so direct primary care is
is Right perfectly situated to be that
that new model because there really is
no substitute for time building trust
takes time I would make my own little
plug for making sure that people are
thinking about the obesity pandemic it
truly truly as a as a disaster in this
41:09
country so whoever you're talking with
make sure they're they've got a good
effective approach for managing obesity
and then I just pitched in here that dr.
Patel mentioned this the incentivizing
use of your thigh right here program is
really important
okay Melina that's all I got yes and so
thank you
doctors very much we do have several
questions in about ten minutes to answer
41:40
some of those so let me start with the
hotel either of you actually either
doctor before uh sure
mark is asking we're building a clinic
in conjunction with a few other area
employers and we're in a rural area can
a DBC staffing work with a nurse
practitioner or physician assistant as
lead at the clinic dr. Patel um yes
nurse practitioners in pas the again I
think the key thing is what level of
42:14
services are we trying to provide for
most part nurse practitioners a PhD
nominal job it's really navigating the
care for the community for the specialty
in your town and of course the resources
sometimes it's hard to recruit our
number one problem right now just
getting the recruit in and moving into
the area where you need help so we have
many practices that do run on nurse
practitioners and pas today
is thank you dr. usher same question big
42:48
lesson for now yeah no I would agree I
we have among our providers are just
have fantastic
nurse practitioners PA staff who I
really trust implicitly it's I agree
with dr. Patel it's really a strategy
issue from the standpoint of the
employer and what it is they're trying
to achieve as to how much they want to
put into position versus and B versus PA
there's just some cost differential
43:19
there and recruiting is top recruiting
is tough not everybody sees us as the
quarterbacks thank you um something a
question that I actually have there's
several more questions but I have a
question because we talked about both
models the proximity model and doctor uh
sure
reform medicine handling more than
primary care and I will talk to Ben
about obesity but I handle I analyze I'm
one of the people that look at employers
43:50
data and we know that behavioral health
and musculoskeletal issues are a very
big ticket item and often not only
expensive for our employers but often
difficult to receive care such as
behavioral health could you talk a
little bit about that about other
services that your clinic offers doctor
uh sure I'll start with you and then
move on to dr. Patel sure we have
contracted with licensed professional
counselors to see patients within our
44:24
office space on a pre-business
pre-coated of course since since then
we've learned that gosh patients really
kind of like that via telehealth so that
same counseling a group has been
providing telehealth services for our
folks in the counseling realm so the
patient doesn't even need to come in to
our office so that that has going pretty
well we have not power
cells contracted directly with any kind
44:56
of physical therapy or chiropractic
those kinds of things
some of our employers have contracted
directly with them and have PT on-site
for example and I do think that's a
really valuable service so that's what I
would say about that
thank you dr. Patel yes the
musculoskeletal and the physical therapy
we all of our clinicians are trained in
that direction number one number two we
have one of our health centers right now
45:28
that is having a full time 40 hour on
physical therapists on-site in
conjunction with the clinician so
essentially that relation of employees
have access to a collection and a
physical therapist and we've deployed
that about eight nine months and we're
looking at replicating this similar
model in other areas others based on
size volume in the knee and looking at
even options of doing the smaller
46:01
population that telehealth would be
another option of getting even though
it's physical therapy we could do in as
far as behavioral health and like David
said it's very driven
especially under health and we're
actually looking to recruit folks and MD
to help negate original first sight and
then multiply it across our centers
Thank You doctors
another question by Nicole is Drew
46:33
clinics staffed by physicians people I
will take part of that question I assume
you're asking the Alliance if the
Alliance clinic is stopped staffed by
physicians because clearly before
medicine doctor uh sure is a family
practice physician or still is and you
know will be of course um and so the
answer is yes per octave MD has and the
Alliance have made the commitment to
bring in a physician to staff the first
47:05
clinic that we're going to be offering
but
going back to what dr. Patel and dr.
Osler said we it's a strategic decision
and we absolutely believe in the middle
level provider offering services the
nurse practitioner and the physician
assistant as leads at clinics because
this is first where the Alliance will
will be will we'll have staffing by a
physician okay you or do you have
something to add to that
47:36
since rapport medicine is making that
commitment no I agree I think that's in
line what we're saying thank you and
Nicole if I didn't answer your question
of property please write us and let us
know
another question by mark do most of your
employers in DPC models cover only those
in their plan or do they cover their
entire employee population and is it
making it free critical for maximizing
utilization
48:05
that's a great question mark dr. Patel
is again it's a reform a reform medicine
and profitability have a unique model
here so dr. Patel yeah but so it depends
on employers so a lot of though but most
of our employers
allow their employees that are on the
health plan and their dependents all to
join the DPC model but there are very
few employers I'll say only the
48:36
employees and not the dependents so
again just if they based on within your
needs are thank you and another question
is and I know Tanya I know you're
directing it to reform medicine I think
it is appropriate for both the doctors
if how do we offer MRIs and how do we
recommend war patients go to receive
MRIs David would you mind telling us
49:07
some of the strategies employers are
using for that right so the if I can
pick you back on that last question one
thing I would say is because direct
primary care is not insurance and
players can put anybody on the plan or
allow anybody on the plan they want to
involve again that dr. Patel mention
that's just kind of employer dependent
so you can have part-time employees and
so forth on your plan if you wish what
we do is again we look at what the
49:39
employers network is and usually they'll
have a high value set of centers that
they've designated as the lowest price
the best deal for getting things like
MRIs cat-scans specialty care and so
forth so we always direct our patients
to that resource person for their plan
and they then can inquire of them what
their options are and then the patient
50:11
lets us know last thing we want to do is
send the patient somewhere out of
network and and line them up in medical
bankruptcy that's just not a very good
wellness strategy for our patients so
that's how we do it basically to make
sure that the patient is interacting
with their health plan and dr. Patel the
same question for you I know the
Alliance and proactive MD we're working
to exchange data so that as the alliance
controls cost data because we control
the contracts you can have information
50:42
of the most and of course integrate with
your quality metrics the high value you
know how to send and word to send to
high value specialists but same question
to you
so specifically you mention about the
MRI or imaging and it also goes to the
specialty services - so in we have 44
clinics total right now and each
community is different so each community
would need to kind of customized in that
area to serve one of the resources how
far do they have to travel to get the
MRI and/or the specialty services and
51:16
each community will we will actually
Kingdom database that says okay if you
think I'm Iraheta or they can you get in
who's making it and what the cost is so
essentially we have a carer navigator a
patient advocate roughly some of this
for the patients of their now cost
the system that's right yes'm we didn't
talk about the patient advocate's but we
will get a an opportunity at a further
at a future webinar to talk about the
patient advocates that come with a Recor
51:47
medicine with the brachot confusing the
names but the drugs MMD model I have two
questions here both regarding our X and
so how do you approach to handling our X
both potentially prepackaged medications
but also our specialty drugs doctor uh
sure
with regard to prescriptions we are just
inherently it's our nature to think use
generics first of course we do dispense
52:21
some prescriptions out of the out of the
office we're actually looking at
painting that in future up the and often
that just dispensing them out of the
office can even save more money than
what occurs under the PBM for example a
pharmacy benefits manager so and that's
really convenient for the patient
particularly if they're not feeling well
you can get them there antibiotics and
so forth they don't have to go stand in
52:52
line at the pharmacy or high blood
pressure drugs or diabetes drugs people
if they can just send them with people
it's a very nice option as far as
specialty care drugs we are working the
same thing occurs with basically the
approach to how you get the MRI done you
kind of put people back and touch with
their health plan work with them as much
as we can understand whether or not they
actually need the medication that's one
of the things that we don't really
53:24
we're not the specialists so we but we
do want to talk with the patient and see
what the specialist is saying about
their medications to make sure that this
is really the best thing for them at the
time and so we'll kind of review that
with them but we will refer people to
patient assistance program sometimes or
a variety of things that maybe help take
some of the costs out but there's as far
as specialty care drug we don't have a
lot of direct control over that dr.
Patel I see my clock it tells me to
53:55
follow one and I have tons of questions
by the way folks on the webinar I would
completely understand if you need to
drop off we will answer these questions
in collaboration with the two doctors
and send to you but dr. Patel I can't
help myself there is more and more
questions I like to address to you and
the question is how do you capture
avoidance of needing a surgery by
improving primary care and this comes to
us from Dan who is actually pains
actually a client of
54:26
Proactive MD currently so it's dumb
when we say surgery let's take
orthopedic surgery musculoskeletal spent
if the patient comes to us the primary
care and we navigate their care and we
manage the imaging imaging back tools
and navigated through the system we're
not saying that they don't need to avoid
surgery we're saying that could there be
other options that are more viable like
54:57
physical therapy and that's why we have
a physical therapist on-site and the
idea behind it is to say if you can care
for the patient early keep them moving
the joint morning and not actually put a
needle in there yet if it needs to so be
it
who we would spend time gradually in
what usually longtime Subin patients
will come in I have knee pain I won't
blame REI a needle I want surgery but
there's this wind of the opportunity
that we're missing and if we can capture
that you'd be surprised
55:27
really surgeries we can going all
together and statistics are astonished
especially for the Muslim world on how
many surgeries can be avoided if we
follow a pattern and so we're really
what we're saying is we want to navigate
with care in the community once they go
along the curve I'm getting a x-ray MRI
and immediately the next thing is just
hope then it's just down that path
fantastic and with not worse three
minutes of our doctors thank you so very
56:00
much for your time we hope to see
everyone again June 23rd for everyone on
the webinar all all of those of you who
I've seen and I cannot see thank you for
the privilege of your time hey thank you
thanks Bob all right thanks everyone see
you